A fabrication estimate needs two clear numbers: what your shop expects the work to cost and what it plans to charge. Estimated cost describes the resources included in your calculation. Selling price is the amount you propose to the customer for the defined scope.
The difference helps explain the price, but it does not automatically tell you the job's final profit. That depends on what the estimate includes and what the job actually consumes. A useful review starts by making the cost basis clear.
Start with the costs included in the estimate
For a fabricated assembly, your estimate might include material, purchased components, labor and outside processing. Handling, equipment and delivery may also belong in the scope. The important question is where each allowance sits in your calculation.
For example, a shop may use a labor rate that includes certain shop expenses. Another estimate may show some of those expenses separately. Before comparing the two, identify what each rate includes. Otherwise, the same expense can be counted twice or omitted altogether.
Keep the labels specific enough that a reviewer can follow the estimate without reconstructing it from memory.
A fictional fabrication quote
Suppose a shop estimates one fabricated assembly using these invented amounts:
| Included estimated cost | Amount |
|---|---|
| Material and purchased components | $1,200 |
| Labor allowance | $900 |
| Outside processing | $300 |
| Total included estimated cost | $2,400 |
The proposed selling price is $3,000. All amounts describe the same assembly and scope, before sales tax. Delivery and installation are excluded. No separate overhead allocation is included in this simplified example.
The difference between the proposed price and the included estimated cost is:
$3,000 − $2,400 = $600
That $600 is the difference on the stated estimate basis. It still has to cover any business expenses not included in the $2,400 before you can describe the remainder as profit. These amounts illustrate the calculation; they are not recommended rates, customer data or a suggested price for your shop.
Markup and margin use different starting points
The same $600 difference can be expressed in two ways:
Markup on the included cost:
$600 ÷ $2,400 × 100 = 25%
Margin relative to the selling price, on the same cost basis:
$600 ÷ $3,000 × 100 = 20%
The dollar difference is unchanged. The percentage changes because markup uses cost as its denominator, while margin uses selling price. A 25% markup is therefore not the same as a 25% margin.
Business Victoria explains these denominator differences in its guide to calculating margin and markup.
In this example, the 20% figure is not a net profit margin: the estimate has not included every business expense. When you discuss a percentage, name both the calculation and the costs behind it.
See what a cost change does to the quote
Now suppose the outside-processing allowance rises from $300 to $450 before the quote is issued. Material and labor remain the same, so the included estimated cost becomes $2,550.
If the proposed selling price stays at $3,000, the difference becomes $450. That is 15% of the selling price, compared with 20% in the first estimate.
The customer-facing number has not moved, but the basis of the pricing decision has. The reviewer needs to decide whether to retain the price, revise it or resolve the supplier question first. A total by itself does not explain that choice.
Review the basis before adjusting the price
Before changing a markup or discount, settle three questions:
- Does the estimate include the work the customer requested?
- Are the hours, rates, quantities and supplier allowances appropriate for that work?
- Which expenses are already included, and which still need to be covered?
A percentage adjustment cannot correct an omitted operation or a misunderstood scope. Review the inputs first, then make the pricing decision. Keep broader checks, such as drawing revision, delivery responsibility and approval, in your final quote review as well.
Keep one quote option on one basis
Compare cost and selling price for the same scope and quantity. A cost for one assembly and a price for a batch describe different things. So do a fabrication-only cost and a price that includes installation.
When the customer requests several quantities, calculate and review each option on its own basis. The separate question of how order totals and unit prices compare belongs in the quantity-break review.
Keep cost and price visible in the review
FabWerks® Estimating's Quote Cost Summary separates Cost and Sell price so the person reviewing a quote can examine both. Your team still decides whether the included costs, scope and proposed price are appropriate for the work.
The goal is a quote whose reasoning another person can follow: what is included, what it is expected to cost and what the customer is being offered.